Get Social With Us!

Call us: (724) 935-5753  

Claims

Need to File a Claim? We Are Here to Help!

During our normal business hours of Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Eastern Time, we encourage our customers to contact us directly for assistance with reporting any claims. On evenings, weekends, or holidays, you can also contact your insurance company directly to file a claim. Below is a list of claim reporting phone numbers, email addresses, or websites for our companies. 

Please have your policy number available when reporting a claim. 

Aegis Security Insurance Company
1-800-233-2160
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
American Strategic Insurance (ASI)
1-866-274-5677
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Auto-Owners Insurance Company
1-888-252-4626
Roadside Assistance: 1-888-869-2642
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Donegal Insurance Group
1-800-877-9006
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Foremost Insurance Company
1-800-527-3907
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Frederick Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-544-8737 (Business Hours)
1-866-212-5246 (After Hours)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Infinity Insurance Company - Classic Collectors Program
1-800-348-4269
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Main Street America Group
(including NGM Insurance Company)
1-877-425-2467
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 Mapfre Insurance Company
1-877-627-3731
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MetLife Auto and Home
1-800-854-6011
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Millers Capital Insurance Company
1-800-745-4555, option 2 (Business Hours)
1-717-585-2918 (After Hours)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mine Subsidence Insurance
1-800-922-1678
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
National Flood Insurance Program
1-800-427-4661 (Customer Service Center)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ohio Casualty Insurance Company
(Commercial Policies Only)
1-866-255-5530
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Peninsula Insurance Company
1-800-492-1205
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company
1-800-765-9749
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Progressive Insurance
1-800-776-4737
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Safeco Insurance
1-800-332-3226
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Philadelphia Contributionship
(including Germantown Insurance Company)
1-800-269-1409
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company
1-800-470-0599
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Share by: